Skip to main content
Start of content
Start of content

441-00197 (Transportation)

Paper petition

Original language of petition: English

Petition to the Hon. Omar Alghabra, Minister of Transport

WHEREAS:

  • In recent years Transport Canada has closed large areas of airspace in the Fraser Valley and Metro Vancouver in BC used for student pilot training;
  • The result of these closures has been a catastrophe for the residents of eastern parts of Maple Ridge BC and western parts of Mission BC;
  • Our otherwise quiet neighbourhoods are now suffering from noise from student pilot training planes and stunt practice planes circling our homes from 7 AM to 11 PM 7 days a week including all holidays;
  • We have witnessed near misses and illegal manoeuvres that were reported to Transport Canada and they said they responded to the flying schools to stop but it had no affect; and
  • This area is becoming know as the Wild West of student pilot training with absolutely no oversite.

We, the undersigned, citizens and residents of Canada, call upon the Hon. Omar Alghabra, Minister of Transport, to:

  • not allow practicing outside of CYA 185, 186 or 188 approved practice areas;
  • move the CYA 185 southern boundary north to stay clear of residential areas;
  • require flyover of training planes on way to CYA 185 to be at 4000' at a cruising speed due to the sheer number and noise from the training planes;
  • not allow stunt planes to practice anywhere near homes or farms and add airspace surveillance and control to prevent flying in illegal conditions or maneuvers;
  • put a moratorium on any new flight schools in the lower mainland of British Columbia until this matter is sorted out; and
  • require tracking devices be installed and operational on all instructional and student planes so they are not turned off during flight as they do now to avoid detection and identification.

Response by the Minister of Transport

Signed by (Minister or Parliamentary Secretary): The Honourable Omar Alghabra

The Aeronautics Act and the Canadian Aviation Regulations (CAR) provide a comprehensive framework through which aviation safety is regulated. Included in this framework are regulations, and guidance material, which address the items outlined in your Petition.

There are no regulatory restrictions or limitations, on the time of day, the volume of traffic, or the type of aircraft that can utilize the airspace over the Lower Mainland. Regulations with respect to ‘Minimum Altitudes and Distances’ and ‘Permissible Low Altitude Flight’ are located at:

https://lois-laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-96-433/FullText.html#s-602.14

https://lois-laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-96-433/FullText.html#s-602.15

Training Areas CYA185 – Alouette Lake, CYA186 – Dickson Lake, and CYA188 – Glen Valley, were established to mitigate the conflict between flight training and transiting aircraft. They also provide flight training and other aircraft based along the Lower Mainland areas to practice. This includes the practice of aerobatic maneuvers. The CARs do not prohibit aerobatic manoeuvres provided that it is not conducted over a built-up area or below 2000’ above ground level.

The regulations do not restrict aircraft to a specific area, or to remain inside the boundaries of a CYA. Therefore, Transport Canada cannot request that aerobatic maneuvers be ceased, Flight Training Units stop flying activities, or a moratorium be placed on new schools, unless such activities is not made in accordance with the CARs.

There is no regulatory requirement for aerobatic or training aircraft to have any type of equipment on board for the purpose of tracking its activities. However, most aircraft carry transponders for the purpose of Air Traffic Control (ATC) radar surveillance in controlled airspace, or airspace that has been designated, as outlined in the Designated Airspace Handbook.  

NAV CANADA is the company responsible for the oversight of air traffic and the airspace within which the traffic flows in Canada. Changes to established routes, or airspace boundaries, such as the southern boundary of CYA185 must first be reviewed by NAV CANADA, as any changes may have an unintended impact on the surrounding airspace and traffic flow. On completion of this review, Transport Canada undertakes a risk assessment to ensure that the level of safety, as well as service, will be maintained or improved, before any changes are made.

Due to the complexity of the airspace in-and-around Vancouver, NAV CANADA is currently completing an Aeronautical Review, with the objective of improving traffic flow and mitigating the congestion in the surrounding areas. In accordance with the regulations, noise abatement procedures, and noise operating restrictions at, and in the vicinity of, individual airports can be developed. The activities outlined in the petition originate from several airports in the Lower Mainland where training, as well as privately owned aircraft, operate. As there are no regulations on aircraft noise beyond the immediate vicinity of an airport, Transport Canada has developed guidance material which is located at:

https://tc.canada.ca/en/aviation/operating-airports-aerodromes/managing-noise-aircraft

In the meantime, allegations of unsafe practices or non-compliance with the regulations should be brought to the attention of the Regional Office for investigation and monitoring. The contact information for the Regional Office in British Columbia is:

Transport Canada Civil Aviation2010-7445 132 StSurrey BC V3W 1J8

E-mail: aviation.pac@tc.gc.ca

Toll-free: 1-800-305-2059

 

Presented to the House of Commons
Marc Dalton (Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge)
February 17, 2022 (Petition No. 441-00197)
Government response tabled
April 4, 2022
Photo - Marc Dalton
Pitt Meadows—Maple Ridge
Conservative Caucus
British Columbia

Only validated signatures are counted towards the total number of signatures.