Skip to main content
Start of content
Start of content

431-00264 (Culture and heritage)

Paper petition

Original language of petition: French

Petition to Mr. Steven Guilbeault, Minister of Canadian Heritage, and Mr. Justin Trudeau, Prime Minister of Canada

Whereas music streaming is generating enormous profits at the moment (for device manufacturers, Internet and cell phone service providers and streaming services), but is not profitable for content creators. We hope that the Government of Canada will play a role by creating and outlining a more viable royalties model for artists in the music industry.

We, musicians, artists, music lovers and music fans, call upon Mr. Steven Guilbeault, Minister of Canadian Heritage, Mr. Justin Trudeau, our Prime Minister, the Copyright Board and the Government of Canada to:

1. Update the private copying regime. Since CDs became obsolete, this levy, which brought in $38 million in 2004, fell below $2 million in just a few years. A fee of $3 per smart phone, the equivalent of the fee charged in Europe, would bring in $40 million per year in levies for Canadian artists.

2. Require the Copyright Board of Canada to set a minimum for streaming royalties, similar to the United States. We would like to see more transparency on how royalties are calculated, in detail, and for these calculations to be made public, for all streaming services.

3. Require Internet and cell phone service providers to make an appropriate contribution to culture and for a percentage of these enormous profits to be redistributed as royalties. Suppliers sell their services as a way to access culture; users are offered free months of Spotify with their phone plans, or a discount on a streaming service with their home Internet service. It is no longer possible to claim that these service providers are neutral conduits for information.

4. Require streaming services to be subject to the same tax rules as Canadian companies; that they pay taxes on their profits in Canada, and that GST be charged for their service, their advertising sales and their user data sales.

Response by the Minister of Canadian Heritage

Signed by (Minister or Parliamentary Secretary): Julie Dabrusin

The Government would like to thank the petitioners for expressing their concerns regarding the remuneration of artists in the music industry.

As you may be aware, a statutory review of the Copyright Act (Act) was launched in March 2018, under the leadership of the Standing Committee on Industry, Science and Technology (INDU). To support the review, the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage (CHPC) conducted a study on remuneration models for artists and creative industries. Together, these committees heard an important number of perspectives on how the Act is working for Canadians, and issued reports that made over 50 recommendations regarding the Canadian copyright framework.

Many issues raised in the context of the review relate closely to the requests made by the petitioners. For example, in its report on the review, CHPC recommended that music streaming services be regulated like other Canadian music services, and that tariffs for online music services be reviewed by the Copyright Board to ensure royalty payments provide fair compensation for artists. Meanwhile, INDU recommended that the Government “study the private copying regimes in place in other countries, with a view to identifying the digital environment, the distribution of royalties flowing from the private copying levy, and the impact on consumers on which a private copying levy applies, including the impact of the private copying regime on the retail prices of the different types of digital device to which they apply.”

In light of the recommendations of the review, the Minister of Canadian Heritage, and the Minister of Innovation, Science and Industry, were tasked in their December 2019 mandate letters with reviewing the Act. As such, Government officials have been studying the committees’ recommendations with a view to ensuring that Canada has a healthy and transparent copyright framework, where creators and innovators alike can reap the full rewards of their hard work and investments, and Canadians can easily and confidently access a wide variety of content.

Regarding the Copyright Board’s role in rights holder and creator remuneration, the Government has taken significant action to address the longstanding issue of decision-making delays in Board proceedings, including a 30 percent increase in the Board’s annual funding, the appointment of a new Vice-Chair and additional Board members, and extensive amendments to the Board’s legislative framework. The immediate objective of these new measures is to facilitate faster decision-making, which in turn is expected to facilitate rights holder and creator remuneration while also minimizing costs of such persons or their representative bodies in Board proceedings, among other benefits.

Response by the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Finance

Signed by (Minister or Parliamentary Secretary): The Honourable Chrystia Freeland

Department of Finance Canada - Part 4

The Government is committed to ensuring that companies in all sectors, including digital enterprises, pay their fair share in respect of their activity in Canada.  To this end, Canada has been actively working with our international partners to develop a harmonized approach. Canada and the other members of the OECD-led

Inclusive Framework on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting, with the support of the G20, have been engaged in an extensive policy development process, seeking multilateral agreement on revisions to the international tax framework to account for the challenges of digitalization.

With respect to the Goods and Services Tax (GST), goods and services purchased by Canadians over the internet for use in Canada, including streaming services, are generally subject to tax.  Canadian companies that sell goods and services over the internet to Canadians are generally required to register, collect, and remit the GST on their sales.  Foreign companies that have no physical presence in Canada are generally not required to register and collect the GST on their internet sales to Canadians.  Where physical goods are purchased online from a non-resident company that is not registered for the GST, the applicable GST on those goods would generally be collected by the Canada Border Services Agency at the time the goods are imported into Canada. 

The Government is committed to ensuring that international digital companies whose products are consumed in Canada collect and remit the same level of tax as Canadian digital companies.

Presented to the House of Commons
Denis Trudel (Longueuil—Saint-Hubert)
June 16, 2020 (Petition No. 431-00264)
Government response tabled
September 24, 2020
Photo - Denis Trudel
Longueuil—Saint-Hubert
Bloc Québécois Caucus
Quebec

Only validated signatures are counted towards the total number of signatures.